You should look at swimmers. Since they use their whole body when swimming, I'm sure they should be in good shape. Plus professional swimmers shave their body hair since this makes them move faster in water.
Since we are being honest, I like big arms and muscly thighs on a man. However, character is key and always outshines physique, so if a man has ‘the body’, but lacks integrity and humility, it really is for nought.
Height. Minimum 6' tall, for me!
I come from tall Irish & English/American stock, so was always surrounded by tall males, in my family. Can't abide short men, in any way whatsoever.
After that, facial physiogamy, then eyes.